test rank

Quesadillas from scratch — the masa version vs the flour version

2 replies
2 views

A quesadilla from fresh masa and a quesadilla from a flour tortilla are genuinely different things and it took me years to stop thinking of one as the standard and the other as an alternative. Fresh masa quesadilla: formed by hand directly around the cheese, sealed, cooked directly on the comal. No separate tortilla. The masa and cheese become one structure. This is the traditional version in much of Mexico City street food. Flour quesadilla: the version most people outside Mexico know — cheese between two flour tortillas or folded in one, cooked in a pan. Crispy, layered, easy to make at scale. Both are valid. Both are different. The fresh masa version requires skill (the dough needs the right hydration, the fold needs to be quick) but the result is something the flour version cannot approximate.

T

taco_purist

test rank

The masa quesadilla is the original and it is what people are eating when they eat a 'real' quesadilla in Mexico City. The structure is different — the corn dough cooks around the cheese and creates a sealed pocket with a texture that no folded flour tortilla can replicate. Learning this technique changed what quesadilla meant to me.

C

corn_not_flour

test rank

The fresh masa version is also more forgiving than people expect once the hydration is right. The dough should feel like soft clay — not sticky, not dry, not cracking. Press a small amount around a piece of Oaxacan cheese, seal quickly, onto a medium comal for 3-4 minutes per side.

Sign up

Login to the community