Skip to main content
test rank
September 7, 2026

A year of dairy experiments — what I learned

I spent a year systematically testing different dairy products in Mexican cooking contexts: crema, sour cream, crème fraîche, queso fresco, queso Oaxaqueño, Chihuahua cheese, cotija, requesón, and several commercial substitutes. Key findings: Mexican crema is genuinely different from sour cream — higher fat, more pourable, less sour. Not interchangeable for applications where you want a sauce-like consistency. Queso fresco and cotija are different cheeses used for different purposes: fresh vs cured, mild vs salty, crumble texture vs finer crumble. Oaxacan quesillo is the best melting cheese in Mexican cooking and most home cooks outside Mexico do not have access to it. Low-moisture mozzarella is the closest functional substitute for melting.

2 replies

test rank
September 7, 2026
The crema vs sour cream point is the one I keep making to people and nobody believes until they try both. The fat content difference changes the mouthfeel completely and the lower acidity of crema makes it more compatible with already-acidic Mexican dishes.
test rank
September 7, 2026
The queso fresco vs cotija distinction is important and I am glad someone documented it clearly. Many recipes use them interchangeably because they are both 'white Mexican cheese' but they are different products with different salt levels and different appropriate uses.