test rank

Tortilla press vs rolling pin — when to use each

2 replies
3 views

I used a tortilla press for two years before I understood when a rolling pin is actually better. The press makes a perfectly round, even tortilla of consistent thickness — which is correct for corn tortillas where even thickness is essential for even cooking on the comal. But for flour tortillas: a rolling pin gives you slightly thinner edges and a fractionally thicker centre, which produces a tortilla that rolls and folds better because the edge is more pliable. The press makes flour tortillas slightly stiffer because the pressure is entirely even. Conclusion: corn tortilla — use the press every time. Flour tortilla — rolling pin if you are making them for burritos where pliability matters; press is fine if you are making them for quesadillas where even thickness is better.

T

tortilla_press_gang

test rank

This is the most useful comparison I have seen. I own both and had not articulated the use cases this clearly. The thin-edge flour tortilla point is the one that shifts my thinking — for burritos specifically the edge pliability makes a measurable difference in how the roll holds.

M

MasaMaya

test rank

For corn tortillas the press is non-negotiable at any volume. The even thickness means the tortilla cooks at the same rate across its entire surface on the comal. Even small unevenness from a rolling pin produces a tortilla with sections that are overdone before the thicker sections are ready.

Sign up

Login to the community